Original article

Scand J Work Environ Health 2014;40(3):252-265    pdf full text

doi:10.5271/sjweh.3416

Cost-efficient assessment of biomechanical exposure in occupational groups, exemplified by posture observation and inclinometry

by Trask C, Mathiassen SE, Wahlström J, Forsman M

Objectives This study compared the cost efficiency of observation and inclinometer assessment of trunk and upper-arm inclination in a population of flight baggage handlers, as an illustration of a general procedure for addressing the trade-off between resource consumption and statistical performance in occupational epidemiology.

Methods Trunk and upper-arm inclination with respect to the line of gravity were assessed for three days on each of 27 airport baggage handlers using simultaneous inclinometer and video recordings. Labor and equipment costs associated with data collection and processing were tracked throughout. Statistical performance was computed from the variance components within and between workers and bias (with inclinometer assumed to produce “correct” inclination angles). The behavior of the trade-off between cost and efficiency with changed sample size, as well as with changed logistics for data collection and processing, was investigated using simulations.

Results At similar total costs, time spent at trunk and arm inclination angles >60 ° as well as 90th percentile arm inclination were estimated at higher precision using inclinometers, while median inclination and 90th percentile trunk inclination was determined more precisely using observation. This hierarchy remained when the study was reproduced in another population, while inclinometry was more cost-efficient than observation for all three posture variables in a scenario where data were already collected and only needed to be processed.

Conclusions When statistical performance was measured only in terms of precision, inclinometers were more cost-efficient than observation for two out of three posture metrics investigated. Since observations were biased, inclinometers consistently outperformed observation when both bias and precision were included in statistical performance. This general model for assessing cost efficiency may be used for designing exposure assessment strategies with considerations not only of statistical but also cost criteria. The empirical data provide a specific basis for planning assessments of working postures in occupational groups.

This article refers to the following texts of the Journal: 1995;21(1):15-23  1995;21(3):215-222  1999;25(2):81-83  2001;27(2):125-132  2007;33(5):358-367  1992;18(6):361-367
The following article refers to this text: 2016;42(2):125-134